| Name | Score | Price | City |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anchor Bar | 0 | $18.80 | Buffalo |
| Macy's Place Pizzeria Kenmore | 9.3 | $23.84 | Buffalo |
| Mustachio's Pizzeria | 8.6 | $23.34 | Buffalo |
| Imperial Pizza | 8.7 | $33.21 | Buffalo |
| Abbott Road Pizza | 7.7 | $23.21 | Buffalo |
| Brick Oven Bistro | 8.1 | $15.77 | Buffalo |
| Bocce Club Pizza | 8.3 | $29.45 | Amherst |
| Mister Pizza | 8.5 | $23.16 | Amherst |
| Zetti's Pizza & Pasta | 8.6 | $24.02 | Amherst |
| Blaze Pizza | 6.8 | $15.17 | Amherst |
| Anchor Bar | 7.8 | $29.90 | Amherst |
| My Tomato Pie | 6.4 | $22.84 | Amherst |
| Gino & Joes Pizza | 8.3 | $23.38 | Buffalo |
| Just Pizza | 8.6 | $25.56 | Buffalo |
| Mineo's South Pizzeria | 8.2 | $21.32 | Buffalo |
| Ricotta's Pizza | 8.5 | $22.84 | Buffalo |
| Allentown Pizza | 7.9 | $25.23 | Buffalo |
| Extra Extra Pizza | 7.6 | $29.36 | Buffalo |
| Broadway Pizza | 8.5 | $20.73 | Niagara Falls |
| Buzzy’s Pizzeria | 8.1 | $18.85 | Niagara Falls |
| Leon's Italian Bistro & Pizza | 7.8 | $16.74 | Niagara Falls |
| Mr Ventry's Pizza | 7.6 | $18.36 | Niagara Falls |
| Joey's Pizzeria | 8.1 | $17.70 | Niagara Falls |
| Brando's Pizza & Wings | 8.4 | $21.60 | Niagara Falls |
| La Hacienda Ristorante | 8.7 | $21.06 | Niagara Falls |
| 716 supreme subs | 8.4 | $16.20 | Niagara Falls |
| Ghada Have It! | 7.9 | $16.19 | Niagara Falls |
| Casa Nova Restaurant | 8.6 | $21.06 | Niagara Falls |
| Mister B's Restaurant | 8.7 | $19.39 | Niagara Falls |
| Sammy's Pizzeria | 8.9 | $17.05 | Niagara Falls |
| Gagster's Restaurant | 8.3 | $23.92 | Niagara Falls |
| Goodfellas Pizzeria | 7.4 | $21.40 | Niagara Falls |
| Frankies Donuts | 8.5 | $17.50 | Niagara Falls |
| Pizza Oven | 6.7 | $21.00 | Niagara Falls |
| Wise Guys Pizza | 8.2 | $24.74 | Buffalo |
| Artone's Pizza & Subs | 8.4 | $20.65 | Buffalo |
| Emergency Pizza | 8.6 | $25.28 | Buffalo |
| Leo's Pizzeria | 8.1 | $23.73 | Buffalo |
| Great Lakes Pizza | 8.7 | $23.64 | West Seneca |
| Diva's Pizza | 8.2 | $20.70 | Buffalo |
| Jo Jo's Pizza & Subs | 7.8 | $22.84 | Buffalo |
| Pizza By Molino's | 8.8 | $20.12 | Buffalo |
| One Pie Pizza Co | 8.5 | $24.99 | Buffalo |
| Jet's Pizza | 7.3 | $17.99 | Buffalo |
| La Nova Pizzeria | 7.8 | $31.52 | Buffalo |
| Gino's Pizza Place | 8.8 | $28.00 | Tonawanda |
| DiPaulo's Pizzeria | 8.9 | $23.65 | Tonawanda |
| T.C. Wheelers Bar & Pizzeria | 8.1 | $26.92 | Tonawanda |
| Mayors pizza | 8.3 | $21.55 | North Tonawanda |
| Galassi's Sub Shop | 8.4 | $23.22 | North Tonawanda |
| Franco's Pizza | 7.9 | $29.79 | North Tonawanda |
| The Grill on Erie | 7.5 | $25.36 | North Tonawanda |
| The Wurlitzer Pizza Co | 7.3 | $23.49 | North Tonawanda |
| Good Guys Pizza | 8.6 | $21.50 | North Tonawanda |
| Joe's New York Style Pizza | 8.5 | $24.96 | North Tonawanda |
| A Touch of Italy | 8.2 | $23.10 | Tonawanda |
| Caputi's Sheridan Pub | 8.6 | $15.22 | Tonawanda |
| Favorites Pizza & Wings | 8.9 | $21.15 | Lewiston |
| Hustler's Tavern | 8.7 | $28.08 | Lewiston |
| Vincenzo's Pizza House | 8.2 | $23.00 | Lewiston |
| Main Street Pizzeria | 8.5 | $20.08 | Youngstown |
| Sanger Farm & Bakery | 7.9 | $18.36 | Youngstown |
| Grandma D's Pizzeria | 8.8 | $18.50 | Youngstown |
| Buck's Pizzeria | 7.9 | $19.00 | Niagara Falls |
| Frenchy's Pizzeria | 8.6 | $25.25 | Niagara Falls |